Showing posts with label Marijuana. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Marijuana. Show all posts

Odor of Cannabis and Probable Cause in Florida


Odor of Marijuana Cannabis


 Odor of Cannabis in Florida


"the recent legalization of hemp, and under certain circumstances marijuana, does not serve as a sea change undoing existing precedent, and we hold that regardless of whether the smell of marijuana is indistinguishable from that of hemp, the smell of marijuana emanating from a vehicle continues to provide probable cause for a warrantless search of the vehicle."



NOT FINAL UNTIL TIME EXPIRES TO FILE REHEARING MOTION AND, IF FILED, DETERMINED 

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL 

OF FLORIDA 

SECOND DISTRICT  

EVANS JOSHUA OWENS, ) ) Appellant, ) ) 

v. ) Case No.  2D20-537 ) STATE OF FLORIDA, ) ) 

Appellee. ) ) 

Opinion filed March 31, 2021.  

Appeal from the Circuit Court for Hillsborough County; Kimberly K. Fernandez, Judge. 

Howard L. Dimmig, II, Public Defender, and Richard P. Albertine, Jr., Assistant Public Defender, Bartow, for Appellant. 

Ashley Moody, Attorney General, Tallahassee, and Elba Caridad Martin, Assistant Attorney General, Tampa, for Appellee. 


VILLANTI, Judge.

 

Evans Joshua Owens challenges his judgment and sentence following his guilty plea to the offense of possession of methamphetamine.  He argues that the trial court erred in denying his preserved, dispositive motion to suppress.  Owens argues, in 

pertinent part, that the search of his vehicle was based solely on the odor of marijuana and that because possession of marijuana in some instances, and hemp in all instances, has been legalized in Florida, the odor of marijuana can no longer serve as the basis for probable cause to search a vehicle because the odor of marijuana cannot be distinguished from that of hemp.  We reject this argument and affirm Owens' judgment and sentence.  

We are aware of the decision of the Twentieth Judicial Circuit Court of Florida that held that the smell of marijuana in connection with a traffic stop cannot constitute the sole basis supporting probable cause for a search.  See State v. Nord, 28 Fla. L. Weekly Supp. 511 (Fla. 20th Cir. Ct. Aug. 8, 2020). With all due respect to the capable and experienced circuit judge who authored that opinion, we cannot agree.  Instead, we hold that an officer smelling the odor of marijuana has probable cause to believe that the odor indicates the illegal use of marijuana.  Accordingly, to the extent that it conflicts with this decision, we disapprove of Nord and adopt the opinion of the Ninth Judicial Circuit of Florida in State v. Ruise, 28 Fla. L. Weekly Supp. 122 (Fla. 9th Cir. Ct. Mar. 20, 2020) (holding that an officer who smelled the odor of marijuana during a traffic stop had probable cause for a warrantless search of the vehicle, even though the odor of cannabis was found to be indistinguishable from the odor of now legal hemp). 

We also note that, in this case, the officer was responding to a complaint of reckless and erratic driving; and Owens' odd and erratic responses to the officer's attempts to communicate with him, coupled with the smell, caused the officer to reasonably conclude that Owens should not be "behind the wheel of a vehicle."  Thus, the circumstances supported the officer's conclusion that he had probable cause to 


- 2  

detain Owens and to search his vehicle.1  Finally, we note that even if marijuana was legalized for recreational use, such use while driving would still support the offense of driving while intoxicated; thus, regardless of whether marijuana becomes decriminalized for recreational use, the smell of the burning substance will continue to provide probable cause for a search of a vehicle.  See Johnson v. State, 275 So. 3d 800, 802 (Fla. 1st DCA 2019) ("[E]ven if smoking marijuana were legal altogether, the officers would have probable cause based on the fact that Johnson was operating a car." (citing § 316.193(1)(a), Fla. Stat. (2018))).2  "The probable cause standard, after all, is a 'practical and common sensical standard.'  It is enough if there is the 'the kind of fair probability' on which 'reasonable and prudent people, not legal technicians, act.' " Id. (quoting Florida v. Harris, 568 U.S. 237, 244 (2013)).  

We recognize that there may be a circumstance where an occupant of a vehicle may have a legitimate explanation for the presence of the smell of fresh (not burning or burnt) marijuana in the vehicle, such as where the individual has a lawful prescription for it, or that the substance is, in fact, hemp.  But even the current version of section 381.986, which permits qualified physicians to prescribe the smoking of marijuana as "an appropriate route of administration for a qualified patient," see § 381.986(4)(c),3 continues to prohibit the use of smoked marijuana in vehicles, see 1 As Owens exited the vehicle, the officer saw a plastic bag in plain sight containing a crystal-like substance that was later proven to be methamphetamine. 2


We are confident that in the event marijuana becomes legal for recreational use in Florida, the legislature will amend the statutes pertaining to driving while intoxicated accordingly


. 


3As amended by ch. 2019-1, Laws of Florida. 


- 3 


§ 381.986(1)(j)5 (providing that "medical use" of marijuana does not include use of marijuana on any form of public transportation; in any public place; or on a school bus, vehicle, aircraft, or motorboat "except for low-THC cannabis not in a form for smoking" (emphasis added)).  Cf. Johnson, 275 So. 3d at 802 (holding that even if the driver was a medical marijuana user, this would not defeat probable cause).  

We concede, without affirmatively holding, that such a circumstance (such as where the individual has a lawful prescription or that the substance is hemp) might provide an affirmative defense to a charge of a criminal offense, but it would not prevent the search. Nevertheless, we can think of no circumstance where an affirmative defense might lie where the impetus for the search arose from the smell of burnt marijuana in a vehicle.  

Accordingly, we conclude that the recent legalization of hemp, and under certain circumstances marijuana, does not serve as a sea change undoing existing precedent, and we hold that regardless of whether the smell of marijuana is indistinguishable from that of hemp, the smell of marijuana emanating from a vehicle continues to provide probable cause for a warrantless search of the vehicle. See, e.g., State v. Brookins, 290 So. 3d 1100, 1104 (Fla. 2d DCA 2020) ("Our supreme court has observed that the odor of burnt marijuana emanating from a vehicle—like we have here—provides probable cause to search each of the vehicle's occupants." (citing State v. Betz, 815 So. 2d 627, 633 (Fla. 2002))); accord Johnson, 275 So. 3d at 802. 

Affirmed. 


SLEET and SMITH, JJ., Concur. 

- 4

Science and Florida Prosecutors on Cannabis Prosecution

During the past several years the cannabis issue has been highly politicized. This new policy by the Hillsborough County State attorney's office is based on science. #Refreshing

At least one Tampa, Florida cannabis prosecutor has developed an imminently reasonable and science-based process for determining whether or not cannabis prosecutions will proceed in Hillsborough County, Florida.

"The traditional testimony of officer's training and experience is of no use. These legal products will test positive for THC with the current presumptive test kits in use."

Apparently the roadside, presumptive, field reagent test used by law enforcement cannot accurately detect illegal marijuana. Until such a test is developed, the Tampa Florida based prosecutor will not proceed with many cannabis prosecutions.

During the past several years the cannabis issue has been highly politicized. This new policy by the Hillsborough County State attorney's office is based on science. #Refreshing

"Current field tests are insufficient to establish beyond a reasonable doubt"



MEMORANDUM

TO: All Assistant State Attorneys
Date: September 4, 2019
From: State Attorney Andrew Warren
Re: Prosecution of Marijuana Cases following the enactment of the Hemp law.

Summary:

Effective immediately, our office will not file charges nor prosecute any cannabis case with an offense date on or after July 1, 2019 without a scientifically reliable, admissible test that proves beyond a reasonable doubt that the substance contains a THC level above the 0.3 % threshold that distinguishes illegal cannabis from legal hemp. Among cannabis-related offenses, our office will continue to prioritize felonies: trafficking, manufacturing, delivery, sale, possession with intent, and felony-amount possession cases, while continuing to deprioritize the prosecution of misdemeanor cannabis cases in favor of established diversion and civil citation programs. Also, we will continue to prioritize the prosecution of cannabis-related felonies in which other felonies are part of the same transaction or occurrence, such as felon in possession of a firearm or offenses involving other controlled substances. 

Florida’s new hemp law took effect on July 1, 2019. Since that time, our office has been discussing the prosecutorial impact of the law with elected representatives, other State Attorney’s Offices, and our law enforcement partners. Over the past two months, we have provided guidance consistent with this memorandum within our office while waiting to see what, if any, policy changes our law enforcement partners would make with respect to investigating and arresting cannabis offenses. This memorandum formalizes the guidance ASAs have already been given. 

New Law 

Senate Bill 1020, known as the “Hemp Law,” went into effect on July 1, 2019. This law legalizes the possession and use of hemp. The bill defines hemp as “the plant Cannabis sativa L. and any part of that plant, including the seeds thereof, and all derivatives, extracts, cannabinoids, 2 isomers, acids, salts, and salts of isomers thereof, whether growing or not, that has a total delta-9 tetrahydrocannabinol concentration that does not exceed 0.3 percent on a dry-weight basis.” See Florida Statute §581.217(3)(d). The new law changes the definition of cannabis such that the term excludes hemp as defined in section 581.217. Cannabis and hemp both come from the same plant, Cannabis sativa L. Cannabis and hemp look, feel and smell the same, and both can be smoked. The main difference between hemp and cannabis is that hemp has a total delta-9 tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) concentration that does not exceed 0.3%. If the THC concentration of the plant is less than or equal to 0.3%, then the plant is hemp, and is legal in Florida. If the THC concentration of the plant exceeds 0.3%, then the plant is cannabis and is illegal in Florida (subject to medicinal exceptions).

Impact on Prosecution 

The Hemp Law will impact prosecutors and law enforcement. Specifically, the new law affects our ability to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a substance is illegal cannabis as opposed to legal hemp. Given the inability to distinguish between hemp and cannabis visually or through smell, the only current reliable method is quantitative testing. In order to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a substance is cannabis, we need quantitative testing to establish that the THC level exceeds 0.3% on a dry weight basis. 

Prosecutorial ethics preclude us from charging an offense without a good faith belief that we can prove the offense beyond a reasonable doubt. Accordingly, for any cannabis-related offense occurring on or after July 1, 2019, our office needs a reliable, admissible laboratory test result establishing the suspected substance is illegal cannabis rather than hemp before filing charges. Because, pursuant to Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.191, the speedy trial period starts at the time of arrest, probable cause arrests for cannabis offenses made before law enforcement has obtained a reliable, admissible positive (≥ 0.3% THC) lab test result may jeopardize the successful prosecution of such offenses, absent other circumstances. 

Current field tests are insufficient to establish beyond a reasonable doubt that a substance exceeds the 0.3% THC concentration. Law enforcement agencies locally and statewide are working diligently to develop best practices and procedures to meet this challenge. In the meantime, law enforcement is working with private labs to provide reliable and admissible quantitative testing. A law enforcement agency must submit the suspected substance to a DEAlicensed facility for quantitative testing and ensure that proper chain of custody is preserved. To ensure that the results of any such testing are not excluded by the Court, the particular lab testing methodology utilized must be capable of meeting the Daubert standard. See Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579, 113 S. Ct. 2786, 125 L. Ed. 2d 469 (1993). ACS Laboratory, located in Hillsborough County, is the largest cannabis and hemp testing laboratory in the southeastern United States. ACS Laboratory has advised that it can produce results that will give a quantitative amount of THC in 2-5 business days. More information about ACS Laboratory is available at www.acslabcannabis.com. ASAs should familiarize themselves with the information on the lab practices and procedures necessary to submit evidence of a cannabis offense. 

 The Hemp Law does not affect our current prioritization of cannabis cases. Among cannabis-related offenses, our office will continue to prioritize felonies: trafficking, manufacturing, delivery, sale, possession with intent, and felony-amount possession cases. We will likewise continue to deprioritize the prosecution of misdemeanor cannabis cases in favor of established diversion and civil citation programs. Also, we will continue to prioritize the prosecution of cannabis-related felonies in which other felonies are part of the same transaction or occurrence, such as felon in possession of a firearm or offenses involving other controlled substances. Although we anticipate that law enforcement will direct file charges after obtaining a positive lab result in lieu of making an arrest, whether a defendant is arrested or direct filed will not affect the priority of the prosecution. 

These changes will increase the cost of prosecuting cannabis related offenses. Law enforcement will pay the increased expenses for the necessary quantitative testing prior to our office filing charges. Our office will pay for expert witness testimony to prosecute cannabis cases, subject to the volume of cases and budgetary constraints. 

Impact on Probable Cause Investigations and Admissible Evidence 

As in any prosecution, ASAs must evaluate cannabis cases to ensure the admissibility of evidence. Probable cause to search in cannabis investigations has often been based on odor or plain view from a vehicle or person. As noted above, however, hemp and illegal cannabis look and smell the same. As a result, the Hemp Law creates additional Fourth Amendment challenges related to cannabis-based searches. 

We continue to work with law enforcement to establish best practices to protect people’s Fourth Amendment rights while ensuring successful prosecutions based upon lawful searches and seizures. Under the new Hemp law, the visual observation of suspected cannabis or its odor alone is likely no longer sufficient to establish probable cause to believe a crime is being committed or that evidence of a crime is present. The probable cause standard requires merely a reasonable basis to believe that a crime was committed or that evidence of the crime exists. Accordingly, in most instances, an “odor plus” standard likely demonstrates probable cause to conduct a warrantless cannabis-based search. Many local and statewide law enforcement agencies are adopting this standard. 

Below is a non-exhaustive list of “odor plus” factors. This list provides a starting point for ASAs working through these issues in cases involving warrantless cannabis-based searches. 

1. Information or intelligence regarding illicit activity prior to the stop 
2. Knowledge of the subject’s prior recent criminal history for narcotics violations 
3. Observation of a hand-to-hand transaction prior to the stop 
4. Admission that the substance is illegal cannabis 
5. Conflicting or implausible statements 
6. Nervousness, such as: 
a. Sweating when it is not hot 
b. Shaking or trembling hands 
c. Avoiding eye contact 
7. Furtive movements 
8. Discarding, destroying, or trying to hide a substance 
9. A large amount of currency 
10. Currency in rubber-banded “quick count bundles” 
11. Masking agents such as fabric softener, air fresheners, or coffee grinds 
12. Firearms or other weapons 
13. Drug paraphernalia, such as baggies, pipes, heat sealers, or scales (although legal hemp may be stored in a baggie and smoked in a pipe as well) 
14. Signs of impairment on a driver (such as bloodshot, watery eyes or slurred speech) 

ASAs must assess the documentation of these “odor plus” factors when making evaluations related to charging determinations and admissible evidence. ASAs must always keep in mind that probable cause is assessed under the totality of the circumstances standard, and thus looking for documentation and evidence of circumstances in addition to the sight or odor of cannabis is fundamental to our evaluation of a case. 

Our office will continue to provide guidance as to the latest legal developments related to these Fourth Amendment issues. 

Conclusion 

As these issues work through our court system, we will continue to monitor new court decisions and law enforcement procedures. We intend for this information to help guide your decision-making as you evaluate your cases rather than dictate specific prosecution decisions. Please consult with your supervisors should you have questions or additional thoughts. The recent legal changes make this an evolving area of law, and it is therefore imperative that we continue to communicate effectively to ensure the appropriate and consistent handling of cannabis offenses to advance our mission of public safety, fairness, and justice.

Leon County Cannabis Update September 21, 2019


The traditional testimony of officer's training and experience is of no use. These legal products will test positive for THC with the current presumptive test kits in use.

JACK CAMPBELL
STATE ATTORNEY
301 S. MONROE STREET
TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 32399-255o

TELEPHONE: 8506066000

OFFICE OF
STATE ATTORNEY
SECOND JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF FLORIDA

July 30, 2019

Dear Law Enforcement Partners

I have just returned from our annual Florida Prosecuting Attorney's Summer Conference where our board discussed many significant issues. One of the most pressing is that of Florida's new hemp law and how it impacts other prosecutions. This letter does NOT address medical marijuana. I agree that the issues often interrelate, but for the sake of clarity I only address the hemp issue here.

Both Congress and the Florida Legislature have now passed laws making hemp, CBD, and other derivatives with 3 percent or less of THC, lawful. The specific definition is: "Hemp" means the plant Cannabis sativa L. and any part of that plant, including the seeds thereof, and all derivatives, extracts, cannabinoids, isomers, acids, salts, and salts of isomers thereof, whether growing or not, that has a total delta-9 tetrahydrocannabinol concentration that does not exceed 0.3 percent on a dry-weight basis." Florida Statute  581.217 2019.

Previously, I was present at a meeting and demonstration at the Florida Department of Agriculture on July 8, 2019 where a vendor, a Navy Seal, showed a possible presumptive test that would be able to differentiate these items. They stated they were working with AVO labs and the Broward State Attorney's Office to validate the test. I mentioned that the tests were of no use unless they were validated and that we would need expert testimony to be able to establish their scientific reliability in court.

At the conference, I met with the Broward State Attorney's team and am sorry to report that that they were hoping that AVO was going to be able to both validate and provide the expert testimony necessary. However, they have withdrawn after it was discovered they did not have a DEA License allowing them to even possess marijuana, let alone test it. Hence, I would not recommend you invest in those tests. The current status is that we are hoping to get a presumptive test that will work in Florida, but we don't have it yet. We recommend keeping your current presumptive tests though as they will likely be needed even when the new additional presumptive test is retained.

In addition to presumptive or roadside tests, we also will need full testing for trial. The Attorney General's Chief of Staff and General Counsel have explained the FDLE is currently looking at two possible courses to allow quantification testing of samples. Previously, we would need only qualitative testing as all forms of the cannabis plants were illegal. Now, cannabis and its extracts or derivatives are legal if it has THC concentrations below 3 %

The current posture is that no public or private lab in Florida can do this dispositive testing. The Florida Department of Agriculture is unable to do so, and while there are some private labs that may want to get this business, they are not online as of now. The traditional testimony of officer's training and experience is of no use. These legal products will test positive for THC with the current presumptive test kits in use. The drug sniffing K9s that have been trained on marijuana will likely alert to these products, as they are trained to detect any amount of THC. Hemp products look and smell exactly like marijuana products.

Some municipal labs in larger jurisdictions are also trying to invest in technology that will either allow full or partial quantification. If FDLE does so, or your agency is willing to have the samples privately tested, we will consider filing these cases. I would suggest that if you are contemplating using a non-governmental lab to do your testing, please consult with us. The cost of testing may be far less than what it will cost for us to secure the expert testimony necessary to comply with Florida evidence rules. Furthermore, the lab you are using may not be capable of meeting the Daubert predicate, and if so, the evidence will be excluded. Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharm Inc.. 509 U.S. 579585113 S. Ct. 27862792125 L. Ed. 20469 1993.

My current hope is that the Florida Legislature, Florida Department of Agriculture, and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement will work to resolve this problem. It is clear that cannabis is still illegal, and I intend to enforce the laws as written. While this has created a practical frustration, it does not appear to be insurmountable.

Of greater concerns, are the associated issues we will face due to this status. Much of the search and seizure law hinges on either the officer's or K-9's ability to smell. This seems to now be in significant doubt. I would suggest that your officers and deputies no longer rely purely on their identification of believed cannabis. While it used to allow further detentions and seizures, case law from other jurisdictions suggest it will not be sufficient in the coming months and years.

Finally, perhaps the most egregious oversite is that of juvenile law. At present, there is no additional restriction on children possessing CBD or Hemp. It is my understanding that some shops are now making pre-rolled hemp cigarettes and are selling hemp gummies. The irony that children cannot lawfully possess tobacco but can now have hemp candies and cigarettes is astounding. I again hope that the Florida Legislature will address this problem.

To conclude, this Office will no longer be charging people with possession of cannabis absent a confession to what the substance is or testing by a lab that can meet the evidentiary standards I have laid out. We will also not be approving search warrants or other legal process based on traditional predicates where officers, or their dogs and presumptive tests, feel a substance is cannabis. I know this is a significant change in the law and would caution you in making arrests when these issues are present.

I am confident we can work through these challenges together as we have in the past. We will be lobbying the legislature to fund presumptive testing and final analytical testing, and to regulate possession by minors. Please let me know if you have any questions or concerns.

Your friend,

Jack Campbell
State Attorney

2nd Judicial Circuit

Having a Couple of Marijuana plants in your Florida back yard just got easier


Marijuana Grow, Knock and Talk, marijuana, cannabis

Marijuana Grow Conviction Overturned - Knock and Talk


Having a couple of marijuana plants in your Florida back yard just got easier. A Marijuana grower in Pasco County, Florida's Spring Hill was cleared this week when cops ignored several signs that the guy's home was intended to be private. Aggressive drug law enforcement did not stop at a gate, a beware of dog sign, and a no trespassing sign and came to the residence to knock on the door and talk about information they had received from a tipster. In copspeak this is a "knock and talk."

"After entering the property through this gate, the officers located Mr. Robinson and convinced him to allow them to search the property. They found the two marijuana plants behind Mr. Robinson's house.  This resulted in the State's prosecution of Mr. Robinson for manufacturing marijuana."


ALFRED ROBINSON, v. STATE OF FLORIDA, 

Case No. 2D13-4412

Opinion filed May 22, 2015. 

Appeal from the Circuit Court for Pasco County; Mary Handsel, Judge. 

ALTENBERND, Judge.

Alfred Robinson appeals a withhold of adjudication and a three-year term of probation for the offense of manufacturing marijuana in violation of section 893.13(1)(a), Florida Statutes (2012).  The withhold of adjudication and sentence were imposed as a result of a plea following the denial of a dispositive motion to suppress. 

The motion to suppress was based on the fact that detectives entered Mr. Robinson's property without a warrant or permission. We conclude that the detectives could not enter the property to conduct a knock and talk or to pursue a consensual encounter with Mr. Robinson without first obtaining his permission to enter the property. We reach this conclusion because the property, a semirural homestead where the detectives found two marijuana plants, was surrounded by a chain-link fence; had a closed gate with a "no trespassing—violators will be prosecuted" sign and a "beware of dog" sign; and had a mailbox accessible from outside the fence. These facts distinguish this case from Nieminski v. State, 60 So. 3d 521 (Fla. 2d DCA 2011).  Accordingly, the trial court was required to grant the motion to suppress.  We remand for the trial court to vacate the withhold of adjudication and sentence and dismiss the proceeding.

On July 24, 2012, three detectives went to Mr. Robinson's property on a semirural road in Spring Hill, Florida. They were investigating an anonymous tip that the house on the property was used to grow marijuana. It is undisputed that the detectives did not have a warrant and had not performed an investigation to establish probable cause for such an offense.  When they arrived, they discovered that the property, a small acreage, was completely surrounded by a chain-link fence. The only entrance gate was closed but not locked. Although the detectives did not recall any signs on the property, the trial court found that both a "no trespassing" sign and a "beware of dog" sign were posted at the entrance. The mailbox was on a post at the fenced line outside the gate so that the mailman did not need to enter the property.

After entering the property through this gate, the officers located Mr. Robinson and convinced him to allow them to search the property. They found the two marijuana plants behind Mr. Robinson's house.  This resulted in the State's prosecution of Mr. Robinson for manufacturing marijuana.

Mr. Robinson filed a motion to suppress arguing that the detectives' entry onto his property was an illegal search and that the State had failed to prove that his subsequent consent to search was voluntary. The trial court denied the motion based on this court's decision in Nieminski. On appeal, the parties agree that the dispositive issue is whether the detectives were authorized to enter the property without a warrant or consent.

Our decision in Nieminski involves a similar anonymous tip and a similar fence, but the opinion emphasizes that the "property was not posted with 'no trespassing' signs" and "did not have any other signs that might discourage a person from entering."  Id. at 522-23. There was no evidence to establish the location of the mailbox.  This court held that Mr. Nieminski failed to establish that he had a reasonable expectation of privacy that included the right to assume ordinary citizens would not open his gate and knock on his front door. See id. at 528-29.

Unlike Mr. Nieminski, Mr. Robinson did establish that he had a reasonable expectation of privacy in this property because ordinary citizens would not disregard his threat of prosecution and the risk of a bad dog to enter through his closed but unlocked gate. This case is more similar to the cases distinguished in Nieminski and to this court's recent decision in Ferrer v. State, 113 So. 3d 860 (Fla. 2d DCA 2012). 

In the trial court, because the entry onto the property was found to be lawful, the State was only required to prove that Mr. Robinson's consent was voluntary by the preponderance of the evidence. See Faulkner v. State, 834 So. 2d 400, 403 (Fla. 2d DCA 2003). Had the trial court found the entry to be unlawful, the State would have faced the heavier burden of overcoming the presumption that Mr. Robinson's consent was not voluntary by clear and convincing evidence.  See id. Without detailing the evidence, we agree with the State's concession on appeal that the evidence would not establish voluntary consent under this heightened standard.

Although we do not have occasion to recede from Nieminski, we note that the Nieminski decision relied significantly on the "reasonable expectation" test derived from Katz v. United States, 389 U.S. 347 (1967). See Nieminski, 60 So. 3d at 524-29. We recognized that the officers in that case may have committed a trespass under section 810.09, Florida Statutes (2008). Id. at 528-29. We discussed cases in which an officer's trespass had not been treated as a violation of the Fourth Amendment based on the Katz analysis. Id.  Since our decision in Nieminski, however, the United States Supreme Court has twice written divided decisions relying upon a pre-Katz trespass analysis. See Florida v. Jardines, 133 S. Ct. 1409 (2013); United States v. Jones, 132 S. Ct. 945 (2012). Whether these cases would now require a different outcome in Nieminski is open for debate but is not a matter that we need to decide today. Reversed and remanded. 
  
CASANUEVA and BLACK, JJ., Concur.  


Marijuana Requires No Laboratory Report in Florida

What happens when Prosecutors use the testimony of a cop, with no testimony from a laboratory to identify the drug, Marijuana / Cannabis?





No Lab Report Needed 
for Weed in Florida 

The following sections are excerpts from the court's marijuana opinion testimony decision that can be found in its entirety here. "The issue before us is whether a police officer’s identification of marijuana, arrived at by sight and smell alone, is admissible experience-based opinion testimony. Because the officer’s opinion was based on his personal knowledge and perception and resulted from a process of everyday reasoning, we hold that the officer’s opinion was admissible as lay opinion testimony under Section 90.701, Florida Statutes."

"We find the officers’ testimony within the 
permissible range of lay
observation and ordinary police experience.”

St Petersburg, Florida Marijuana Civil Citation Program

St Petersburg, Florida
Marijuana Civil
Citation Program
Pinellas County Marijuana Defense Attorneys may soon be out of work. St Petersburg, Florida reviewed the current status of Pinellas County efforts to move towards a diversion program as opposed to an ordinance and recommended the proposed Marijuana Civil Citation Program Ordinance move to a First Reading after review and discussion. Meanwhile, Pinellas County Commissioners continue to delay implementing decriminalization of Cannabis.

St Petersburg, Florida  Marijuana Civil Citation Program


St Petersburg, Florida  City Attorney, Mark Winn, presented a proposed ordinance that makes possession of less than 20 grams of cannabis or paraphernalia a City Code violation. He discussed that this will allow officers the discretion to utilize this non-criminal option instead of charging someone with a misdemeanor. 

"the number of times a person was cited should be limited"


Under the proposed Marijuana Civil Citation Program, the Chief of Police would need to establish written standard operating procedures to guide officers in its use and to provide for consistency. The Pinellas County State Attorney's Office indicated a preference for a countywide ordinance for ease of enforcement and reports that a diversion program was being created to address this same issue. 

Discussion was held regarding implementation of an education, therapeutic or assessment component after the second or third citation, how these citations might affect an individual's status in obtaining or remaining in public housing, whether there should be a community service component, whether the number of times a person was cited should be limited, what are the parameters of the officer discretion (e.g. whether this is an option if another offense is being charged), should this option be available for other minor offenses, and review of citation data at a six or twelve month interval.

"Pinellas County State Attorney's Office indicated a preference for a countywide ordinance for ease of enforcement"


A St. Petersburg City Council member made a motion to request Legal return to the Committee with a second draft incorporating the summarized comments and forward the current draft with these minutes to the appropriate officials with Pinellas County. All members of the City of Petersburg, Public Services & Infrastructure Committee at the Meeting on  March 31, 2016 were in favor of the motion. 

St Petersburg, Florida  Marijuana Civil Citation Program #CannabisLaws #CannabisCommunity #Norml #MarijuanaLaws

Sources:

http://www.stpete.org/committee%20packets/Public%20Services%20and%20Infrasructure%20Committee/2016-04-28%20PSI%20Agenda.pdf



Marijuana Growers in Florida - The First Fab Five

Cannabis, Cultivation of Marijuana, Florida Marijuana Laws, Marijuana, Medical Marijuana
Marijuana Growers in Florida - The First Fab Five
First Fab Five Chosen


Florida marijuana growers took a big step - The State of Florida has announced the first five legal growers. They are established to cover five regions in the state. The closest growhouse to Tampa will be Knox Nursery in lovely Winter Garden where they have an  "[e]xpansive selection of flowers, vegetables, shrubbery & home landscaping essentials."

 Miami got a double-dose, when Costa Farms, a "sprawling family-owned nursery . . . of indoor [and] garden tropical plants." in Miami and Alpha Foliage in Homestead were chosen. These five may have an advantage, if the ballot measure to legalize weed passes the ballot. Here they are with a map: 

The Fabulous Five

  1. Alpha Foliage
  2. Chestnut Hill Nursery
  3. Costa Farms
  4. Hackney Nursery Co Inc
  5. Knox Nursery Inc






Alpha Foliage  
Address: 27600 SW 217th Ave, Homestead, FL 33031
Phone:(305) 245-2220

Chestnut Hill Nursery  
Address: 15105 NW 94th Ave, Alachua, FL 32615
Phone:(386) 462-2820

Costa Farms  
Address: 21800 SW 162nd Ave, Miami, FL 33170
Phone:(800) 327-7074

Hackney Nursery Co Inc  
Address: 3690 Juniper Creek Rd, Quincy, FL 32351
Phone:(850) 442-6115

Knox Nursery Inc  
Address: 940 Avalon Rd, Winter Garden, FL 34787
Phone:(407) 654-1972



6 Drugs The Feds Like to Prosecute and the Consequences

traffic, trafficking, Powder Cocaine,  Marijuana, Methamphetamine, Heroin, Oxycodone, Crack Cocaine
Drugs The Feds Like to Prosecute
Trafficking in these 6 drugs constitutes 97 percent of Federal Drug Prosecutions. How does the DEA, law enforcement, and Federal Prosecutions impact drug trafficking? Sometimes these policy choices impact society in ways that are counter-intuitive. When the focus goes to synthetic opioids like oxycodone, the natural substitute, trafficking in heroin spikes. Recent data shows that the war on pill mills has reduced the supply of pharmaceuticals and driven users to heroin. Heroin overdoses are now spiking. When crack cocaine penalties were reduced, trafficking declined. Here are six drugs to traffic and get a ticket to a federal indictment and prison.

Six Drugs To Get You in Federal Prison

Powder Cocaine 
Marijuana 
Methamphetamine 
Heroin 
Oxycodone 
Crack Cocaine 

Once the Feds target a drug, the prosecutions and prisoners increase. For example, methamphetamine traffickers decreased after 2006 , then increased again since 2009. Once the war on synthetic heroin, also known as oxycodone was commenced, after remaining stable for much of the past decade, the number of heroin traffickers has increased. Although oxycodone trafficking is low compared to other drug types, there has been a substantial increase. 

Once the Feds reduced sentences and focused elsewhere, Crack cocaine trafficking has decreased since 2008 when reductions in crack cocaine penalties were first implemented. Now that legalization has begun, marijuana trafficking now has seen a sharp decline in  2013. With the sometimes unexpected consequences of drug policies in play, one can wonder why these decisions to target certain controlled substances are made and who is calling the shots?

Source: United States Sentencing Commission 

Can Police refuse to accept a Florida Medical Marijuana Patient Card - Chapter 893 Statute if Florida Legalizes Medical Marijuana? - Part 13

Can Police refuse to accept a
Florida Medical Marijuana Patient Card?
Can Police refuse to accept a Florida Medical Marijuana Patient Card?

Under current Florida Drug Laws: Florida Statute 893.13.6(b) If law enforcement confronts a citizen for possession of cannabis, they can and do make an arrest. The issue may arise what if the office wants to ignore the possession of a valid medical marijuana card and refuse to accept the document?

Under my proposed Florida Medical Marijuana Law:  

A state or local law enforcement agency or officer shall not refuse to accept an identification card issued by the department unless the state or local law enforcement agency or officer has reasonable cause to believe that the information contained in the card is false or fraudulent, or the card is being used fraudulently.

What About Florida Marijuana Cooperative Farms - Chapter 893 Statute if Florida Legalizes Medical Marijuana? - Part 12

Florida Marijuana Cooperative
Florida Marijuana Cooperative

Under current Florida Drug Laws: Florida Statute 893.13.6(b) If someone or a group conspire to cultivate marijuana, a person commits a felony.  Possession or cultivation of marijuana are both felonies with forfeiture provisions for the tools and property where the cultivation occurs.

Under my proposed Florida Medical Marijuana Law:  

Qualified patients, persons with valid identification cards, and the designated primary caregivers of qualified patients and persons with identification cards, who associate within the State of Florida in order collectively or cooperatively to cultivate marijuana for medical purposes, shall not solely on the basis of that fact be subject to state criminal sanctions under Chapter 893 of the Florida Statutes.

How Much Marijuana Could be Possessed - Chapter 893 Statute if Florida Legalizes Medical Marijuana? - Part 11

How Much Marijuana
Could be Possessed?
 
How Much Marijuana Could be Possessed? 

Under current Florida Drug Laws: Florida Statute 893.13.6(b) If someone is in possession of not more than 20 grams of cannabis, a person commits a misdemeanor of the first degree. More than 20 grams or distribution or sale or possession of marijuana are all felonies. Possession or cultivation of marijuana are both felonies with forfeiture provisions for the tools and property where the cultivation occurs.

Under my proposed Florida Medical Marijuana Law: A qualified patient or primary caregiver may possess no more than eight ounces of dried marijuana per qualified patient. In addition, a qualified patient or primary caregiver may also maintain no more than six mature or 12 immature marijuana plants per qualified patient.

(b) If a qualified patient or primary caregiver has a doctor’s recommendation that this quantity does not meet the qualified patient’s medical needs, the qualified patient or primary caregiver may possess an amount of marijuana consistent with the patient’s needs.

(c) Counties and cities may retain or enact medical marijuana guidelines allowing qualified patients or primary caregivers to exceed the state limits set forth in subdivision (a).

(d) Only the dried mature processed flowers of female cannabis plant or the plant conversion shall be considered when determining allowable quantities of marijuana under this section.

(e) The Attorney General may recommend modifications to the possession or cultivation limits set forth in this section. These recommendations, if any, may be made only after public comment and consultation with interested organizations, including, but not limited to, patients, health care professionals, researchers, law enforcement, and local governments. Any recommended modification shall be consistent with the intent of this article and shall be based on currently available scientific research.

(f) A qualified patient or a person holding a valid identification card, or the designated primary caregiver of that qualified patient or person, may possess amounts of marijuana consistent with this Statute.

What are the Responsibilities of a Florida Medical Marijuana Caregiver - Chapter 893 Statute if Florida Legalizes Medical Marijuana? - Part 9

What are the Responsibilities
of a Florida Medical Marijuana Caregiver?
What are the Responsibilities of a Florida Medical Marijuana Caregiver?

This series or articles continues with our 9th installment and explores how Marijuana Laws in the Florida Statutes might be changed should the voters, the courts, and/or the legislature be so inclined. Here are some issues that will outline what are the Responsibilities of a Florida Caregiver under the proposed language of the law:

(a) Subject to the requirements of this article, the individuals specified in subdivision (b) shall not be subject, on that sole basis, to criminal liability under Chapter 893. However, nothing in this section shall authorize the individual to smoke or otherwise consume marijuana unless otherwise authorized by this article, nor shall anything in this section authorize any individual or group to cultivate or distribute marijuana for profit.

(b) Subdivision (a) shall apply to all of the following:

(1) A qualified patient or a person with an identification card who transports or processes marijuana for his or her own personal medical use.

(2) A designated primary caregiver who transports, processes, administers, delivers, or gives away marijuana for medical purposes, in amounts not exceeding those established in Chapter 893, only to the qualified patient of the primary caregiver, or to the person with an identification card who has designated the individual as a primary caregiver.

(3) Any individual who provides assistance to a qualified patient or a person with an identification card, or his or her designated primary caregiver, in administering medical marijuana to the qualified patient or person or acquiring the skills necessary to cultivate or administer marijuana for medical purposes to the qualified patient or person.

(c) A primary caregiver who receives compensation for actual expenses, including reasonable compensation incurred for services provided to an eligible qualified patient or person with an identification card to enable that person to use marijuana under this article, or for payment for out-of-pocket expenses incurred in providing those services, or both, shall not, on the sole basis of that fact, be subject to prosecution or punishment under Chapter 893.

What are the Responsibilities of a Florida Medical Marijuana Cardholder - Chapter 893 Statute if Florida Legalizes Medical Marijuana? - Part 8

What are the Responsibilities of a
Florida Medical Marijuana Cardholder?
What are the Responsibilities of a Florida Medical Marijuana Cardholder?

This series continues to explore how Marijuana Laws in the Florida Statutes might be changed should the voters, the courts, and/or the legislature be so inclined. Here are some issues that will outline What are the Responsibilities of a Florida Medical Marijuana Cardholder  under the proposed language of the law:

(a)  A person who possesses an identification card shall:

(1)  Within seven days, notify the county health department or the county’s designee of any change in the person’s attending physician or designated primary caregiver, if any.

(2)  Annually submit to the county health department or the county’s designee the following:

(A)  Updated written documentation of the person’s serious medical condition.
(B)  The name and duties of the person’s designated primary caregiver, if any, for the forthcoming year.

(b)  If a person who possesses an identification card fails to comply with this section, the card shall be deemed expired. If an identification card expires, the identification card of any designated primary caregiver of the person shall also expire.

(c)  If the designated primary caregiver has been changed, the previous primary caregiver shall return his or her identification card to the department or to the county health department or the county’s designee.

(d)  If the owner or operator or an employee of the owner or operator of a provider has been designated as a primary caregiver of the qualified patient or person with an identification card, the owner or operator shall notify the county health department or the county’s designee, pursuant to Chapter 893, if a change in the designated primary caregiver has occurred.

How does the Tampa Police Department Make $500.00 when a vehicle is impounded (even if proven not guilty)?

How does the Tampa Police Department Make
$500.00 when a vehicle is impounded?
How does the Tampa Police Department Make $500.00 when a vehicle is impounded?

Here is the latest shakedown by our police department. The cops pull someone over and bust them for these misdemeanors and tell the impound yard that in addition to the towing fee, the owner must pay $500.00. How and Why?

(b) It shall be a violation of this section and a motor vehicle shall be subject to impoundment whenever the vehicle:

(1) Was used or intended to be used to facilitate the commission or attempted commission of an act of prostitution or lewdness as those terms are defined in F.S. § 796.07; or

(2) Was used, intended, or attempted to be used to facilitate the commission or attempted commission of any misdemeanor violation of F.S. Ch. 893 [ Florida's Marijuana, Cannabis, and Drug Law ]; by any owner or co-owner of said vehicle or by any other person utilizing or occupying said vehicle with the express or implied consent of any owner or co-owner.

Can they get the fee even if the case is not proven beyond a reasonable doubt? Yes. Even if the city cannot prove the owner is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt they still can collect because their code says:

(5) Violation of this section is a civil, not criminal, offense. In any action arising from the impoundment of a motor vehicle pursuant to this section, the court shall determine whether the city has established by clear and convincing evidence that a violation of subsection (b) has occurred.

Source: § 14-30 TAMPA CODE

How long will a Medical Marijuana Card be Valid - Chapter 893 Statute if Florida Legalizes Medical Marijuana? - Part 7

How long will a Florida
 Medical Marijuana Card be Valid ?
How long will a Florida Medical Marijuana Card be Valid ?

This series continues to explore how Marijuana Laws in the Florida Statutes might be changed should the voters, the courts, and/or the legislature be so inclined. Here are some issues that will outline How long will a Medical marijuana Card be Valid under the proposed language of the law:

(a)  An identification card shall be valid for a period of one year.

(b)  Upon annual renewal of an identification card, the county health department or its designee shall verify all new information and may verify any other information that has not changed.

(c)  The county health department or the county’s designee shall transmit its determination of approval or denial of a renewal to the Florida Department of Health.

(d)  The Florida Department of Health shall establish application and renewal fees for persons seeking to obtain or renew identification cards that are sufficient to cover the expenses incurred by the department, including the startup cost, the cost of reduced fees for Florida Medicaid beneficiaries in accordance with subdivision (b), the cost of identifying and developing a cost-effective Internet Web-based system, and the cost of maintaining the 24-hour toll-free telephone number. Each county health department or the county’s designee may charge an additional fee for all costs incurred by the county or the county’s designee for administering the program pursuant to this statute.

(e)  Upon satisfactory proof of participation and eligibility in the Florida Medicaid program, a Florida Medicaid beneficiary shall receive a 50 percent reduction in the fees established pursuant to this section.

Next Up -  What are the Responsibilities of a Florida Medical Marijuana Cardholder?

#MedicalMarijuana


Video - Federal policy on Pot “ludicrous, absurd, crazy.” - Says Congressman

What do you think?

Rep. Steve Cohen (D-TN) called federal policy on pot “ludicrous, absurd, crazy.”

 


Could Florida Medical Marijuana Card be Denied - Chapter 893 Statute if Florida Legalizes Medical Marijuana? - Part 6


How Could a Florida
Medical Marijuana
Card be Denied Issuance?
How Could a Florida Medical Marijuana Card be Denied Issuance?

This series continues to explore how Marijuana Laws in the Florida Statutes might be changed should the voters, the courts, and/or the legislature be so inclined. Here are some issues that will outline How a Medical Marijuana Card could be Denied under the proposed language of the law:

(a)  The county health department or the county’s designee may deny an application only for any of the following reasons:

(1)  The applicant did not provide the information required by Chapter 893 of the Florida Statutes, and upon notice of the deficiency, did not provide the information within 30 days.

(2)  The county health department or the county’s designee determines that the information provided was false.

(3)  The applicant does not meet the criteria set forth in this Chapter 893.

(b)  Any person whose application has been denied pursuant to subdivision (a) may not reapply for six months from the date of denial unless otherwise authorized by the county health department or the county’s designee or by a court of competent jurisdiction.

(c)  Any person whose application has been denied pursuant to subdivision (a) may appeal that decision to the department. The county health department or the county’s designee shall make available a telephone number or address to which the denied applicant can direct an appeal.

Next Up - How long will a Florida Medical Marijuana Card be Valid ?

#MedicalMarijuana

How will the State of Florida be required to process Medical Marijuana Applications - Chapter 893 Statute if Florida Legalizes Medical Marijuana? - Part 5

How will
 Florida process
Medical Marijuana Applications?
How will the State of Florida be required to process Medical Marijuana Applications?

This series continues to explore how Marijuana Laws in the Florida Statutes might be changed should the voters, the courts, and/or the legislature be so inclined. Here is an outline of how the State of Florida could be required to process Medical Marijuana Applications under the proposed language of the law:

(a)  Within 30 days of receipt of an application for an identification card, a county health department or the county’s designee shall do all of the following:

(1)  For purposes of processing the application, verify that the information contained in the application is accurate. If the person is less than 18 years of age, the county health department or its designee shall also contact the parent with legal authority to make medical decisions, legal guardian, or other person or entity with legal authority to make medical decisions, to verify the information.

(2)  Verify with the Florida Department of Health that the attending physician has a license in good standing to practice medicine or osteopathy in the state.

(3)  Contact the attending physician by facsimile, telephone, or mail to confirm that the medical records submitted by the patient are a true and correct copy of those contained in the physician’s office records. When contacted by a county health department or the county’s designee, the attending physician shall confirm or deny that the contents of the medical records are accurate.

(4)  Take a photograph or otherwise obtain an electronically transmissible image of the applicant and of the designated primary caregiver, if any.

(5)  Approve or deny the application. If an applicant who meets the requirements of  Chapter 893 can establish that an identification card is needed on an emergency basis, the county or its designee shall issue a temporary identification card that shall be valid for 30 days from the date of issuance. The county, or its designee, may extend the temporary identification card for no more than 30 days at a time, so long as the applicant continues to meet the requirements of this paragraph.

(b)  If the county health department or the county’s designee approves the application, it shall, within 24 hours, or by the end of the next working day of approving the application, electronically transmit the following information to the department:

(1)  A unique user identification number of the applicant.
(2)  The date of expiration of the identification card.
(3)  The name and telephone number of the county health department or the county’s designee that has approved the application.

(c)  The county health department or the county’s designee shall issue an identification card to the applicant and to his or her designated primary caregiver, if any, within five working days of approving the application.

(d)  In any case involving an incomplete application, the applicant shall assume responsibility for rectifying the deficiency. The county shall have 14 days from the receipt of information from the applicant pursuant to this subdivision to approve or deny the application.

Next Up - What Information will a Florida Medical Marijuana Card Contain?

How to Apply for Medical Marijuana Cards - Chapter 893 Statute if Florida Legalizes Medical Marijuana? - Part 4

How to Apply for Florida
Medical Marijuana Cards?
How to Apply for Florida Medical Marijuana Identification Cards?

This series continues to explore how Marijuana Laws in the Florida Statutes might be changed should the voters, the courts, and/or the legislature be so inclined. Here are some issues that will outline How to Apply for Medical Marijuana Cards under the proposed language of the law:

(a) A person who seeks an identification card shall pay a fee and provide all of the following to the county health department or the county’s designee on a form developed and provided by the department:

(1) The name of the person, and proof of his or her residency within the county.

(2) Written documentation by the attending physician in the person’s medical records stating that the person has been diagnosed with a serious medical condition and that the medical use of marijuana is appropriate.

(3) The name, office address, office telephone number, and Florida medical license number of the person’s attending physician.

(4) The name and the duties of the primary caregiver.

(5) A government-issued photo identification card of the person and of the designated primary caregiver, if any. If the applicant is a person under 18 years of age, a certified copy of a birth certificate shall be deemed sufficient proof of identity.

(b) If the person applying for an identification card lacks the capacity to make medical decisions, the application may be made by the person’s legal representative, including, but not limited to, any of the following:

(1) A conservator with authority to make medical decisions.

(2) An attorney-in-fact under a durable power of attorney for health care or surrogate decisionmaker authorized under another advanced health care directive.

(3) Any other individual authorized by statutory or decisional law to make medical decisions for the person.

(c) The legal representative described in subdivision (b) may also designate in the application an individual, including himself or herself, to serve as a primary caregiver for the person, provided that the individual meets the definition of a primary caregiver.

(d) The person or legal representative submitting the written information and documentation described in subdivision (a) shall retain a copy thereof.

In our next installment we will address: How will the State of Florida be required to process Medical Marijuana Applications?

Florida Amphetamine or Methamphetamine Minimum Mandatory Law

Florida Statute § 893.135  Amphetamine or Methamphetamine Minimum Mandatory Sentences

Florida laws on Amphetamine or Methamphetamine provide harsh minimum mandatory sentences that kick-in at 14 grams. The stakes become higher when 28 grams are alleged and proven by admissible evidence to a jury and/or sentencing judge in Florida State Courts. A 15 year minimum prison sentence is possible at 200 grams.

The United States Code also provides harsh sentences for trafficking in this controlled substance. At 50 grams a life sentence is possible for certain defendants.See 21 USC §§ 841(a), 841(b)(1)(A); § 2D1.1  for more information.

Amphetamine or methamphetamine

14 – 28 grams
3 years, $50,000 fine

28 – 200 grams
7 years, $100,000 fine


200+ grams

15 years, $250,000 fine