Showing posts with label Affidavit for Search Warrant. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Affidavit for Search Warrant. Show all posts

Marijuana Search - Protective Safety Sweep

Tampa Florida Criminal Defense Lawyer, Search and seizure, Residence, possession of  marijuana, possession of  cannabis, Affidavit for Search Warrant, Probable Cause, Search Warrant, odor, Protective Sweep
Marijuana Search
Protective Safety Sweep
Tampa Florida Criminal Defense Lawyer notes a recent Search and seizure case involving a Residence and a Search Warrant. The Second District Court ruled that the protective sweep of the possession of marijuana defendant's residence was improper. The court noted no basis for concern that drug evidence might be destroyed before a search warrant could be obtained.

Marijuana Search - Safety Sweep


The appeals court also found no facts to support a reasonable belief that there was a person in the residence who could pose a danger to law enforcement. The observation of narcotics by officers during an improper protective sweep cannot be a valid basis for issuance of search warrant, even so, since the officers smelled marijuana when the suspect opened front door after officers had lawfully approached residence and knocked on front door,  probable cause for issuance of warrant was found.

When the court finds that police unlawfully obtained some of evidence contained in an affidavit or application for a search warrant, the trial court must then determine if there was probable cause to support issuance of warrant based on any independent and lawfully obtained evidence. The trial court committed error in granting the  motion to suppress because probable cause for issuance of warrant was established without considering evidence obtained in improper protective sweep.

Case Excerpts:

"[T]he sweep of the house was improper based on the concern that evidence may be destroyed because there were no facts supporting an objectively reasonable basis for the belief that someone inside the house could destroy evidence while the warrant was being obtained. See United States v. Rivera, 825 F.2d 152, 156 (7th Cir. 1987) ("In determining whether the agents reasonably feared imminent destruction of the evidence, the appropriate inquiry is whether the facts, as they appeared at the moment of entry, would lead a reasonable, experienced agent to believe that evidence might be destroyed before a warrant could be secured.")."

"[T]here was no evidence that the house was occupied, the trial court correctly found that the protective sweep of the house for officer safety was improper as there were no specific and articulable facts supporting a reasonable belief that there was an individual in the house who could pose a danger to law enforcement. See Maryland v. Buie, 494 U.S. 325, 337 (1990) ("The Fourth Amendment permits a properly limited protective sweep in conjunction with an in-home arrest when the searching officer possesses a reasonable belief based on specific and articulable facts that the area to be swept harbors an individual posing a danger to those on the arrest scene.")."

"Where a court finds that police unlawfully obtained some of the evidence contained in the application for the 
search warrant, the court must then determine if there is probable cause to support the issuance of the warrant based on any independent and lawfully obtained evidence. Id. “[T]he court must excise the invalid allegations from the affidavit and determine whether sufficient valid allegations remain to support a finding of probable cause.” State v. Hood, 68 So. 3d 392, 395 (Fla. 2d DCA 2011)."


Source: STATE OF FLORIDA, v. IDALIA ROMAN Case No. 2D11-769 (Fla 2d DCA Nov. 7 2012).

Search Warrant | Video | Knock and Announce Shooting

Knock Announce Resident Killed
Florida Drug Defense Attorney has obtained video of a military-style entry into a home by drug / narcotics cops. A resident was shot and killed seconds after the Search Warrant entry. In Florida, we have discussed the knock and announce rule. You can read more here.

As we previously noted, the "Exclusionary Rule will be applied to violations of Florida's statutory knock-and-announce rule, according to an appellate court. The court found that a police officer violated Florida's knock-and-announce arrest statute where officer knocked and announced his presence, but failed to announce his purpose before entering motel room and arresting defendant. The court held that it was error to deny the defense motion to suppress evidence seized from motel room and statements made by defendant regarding that evidence."



Knock and Announce Violation? Call Me at 813-222-2220

Drug Search Warrant for Marijuana | Reversed on Appeal | Tampa Appeal Lawyer Kenneth Siegel

Conviction for Manufacture of Cannabis
Manufacture Cannabis

Conviction for Manufacture of Cannabis 


Tampa Drug Defense Attorney notes that my good friend Tampa Appeal Lawyer, Ken Siegel  had  a cannabis client's conviction overturned. The defendants "were each charged with manufacture of cannabis, possession of cannabis, and possession of drug paraphernalia as a result of evidence seized during the search of their home." The court found the following language in the Affidavit for Search Warrant did not provide Probable Cause for the Search.

The citizen informant "specifically named [Name Omitted] , provided her vehicle descriptions, tag number and phone number in the messages. He also provided information on her new employment. The citizen specifically stated that [Name Omitted] and her boyfriend, [Name Omitted] were growing marijuana plants in their home and selling cocaine from the residence."

The Court ruled, "The affidavit contained no allegations that anyone actually saw contraband in the couple's residence and there were no facts from which the magistrate could conclude that contraband was and would still be located in the residence at the time the warrant issued. See Rand v. State, 484 So. 2d 1367, 1367 (Fla. 2d DCA 1986) (finding affidavit insufficient for failing to allege the specific time or times when contraband was observed on the premises)." The Second District ruled "We disagree and find that the good faith exception is inapplicable in this case."

Cannabis Charge Appeal Questions? Call Me Toll Free 1-877-793-9290.


Drug Search Warrant  Marijuana

Source: Case No. 2D09-844